Rating NYC Cookies
March 19, 2026
PlaceFood/Recipe
🍪
Thick Cookie - Culture Espresso delivers the absolute best thick NYC style cookie, period.
✨
Thin Perfection - From Lucie serves a faultless thin cookie with perfect salty vibes.
❌
Skip Crumbl - This overhyped spot is a total mess with claggy dry textures.
🤤
Chewy Bliss - L'Appartement 4F offers a solid chewy cookie that melts in mouth.